Do you agree that Karen’s feet should be cut off as a punishment? Why or why not?

Yes, I agreed.
Because Karran in old woman falling ill period has not looked after her, actually runs attends the dance party.
Puts on the red dance shoes to upspring the dance to come, but the red shoes actually likely received the curse not to listen to Karran's words.
Finally must excise this both feet to be able to cause the dance shoes not to dance, treats as the punishment!

So you think she is really vicious?

Karran is naive viciously by no means!
Story she is also finally willing the mistake which violates for her, the excision both feet to confess the crime

Cut off her feet to be punished was too serious.Although she was make mistakes, also is receives the red shoes tempting.Like this she is too pitiful.

Yes, I agree with it. Because she left old lady and go to ball, as a punishment, her feet should be cut off.

Yes, he did not listen to the advice.
Although this is very brutal.

NO,I think before cut her feet, she already knew that she also has felt mistakenly the fear, cut the feet to take the punishment to be a little cruel.

No,Karren knew her mistake finally.
Cutting her feet is too serious.